The Effects of Pre-admonition Suggestions on Eyewitnesses’ Choosing Rates and Retrospective Identification Judgments

Date
2017
Authors
Quinlivan, Deah S.
Wells, Gary L.
Neuschatz, Jeffrey S.
Luecht, Katherine M.
Cash, Daniella K.
Key, Kylie N.
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Springer
Abstract
Pre-admonition suggestion is an identification-relevant comment made to an eyewitness by a lineup administrator before the lineup admonition. Quinlivan et al. (2012) found that their suggestion inflated mistaken identification rates and retrospective identification. However, the suggestion used was a compound statement, making it unclear which component influenced choosing rates. The current experiment was conducted to parse out the effects. Participants (N = 211) viewed a crime video and received either one component of the compound suggestion (a suggestion to pick or that the witness had paid substantial attention), both components, or no suggestion. All participants received an admonition, made an identification choice, and answered questions about their witnessing experience. The results demonstrated that the pick suggestion increased mistaken identifications from a perpetrator-absent lineup whereas the effects of the attention suggestion were restricted to the retrospective judgments. These results show support for the role of secondary (non-memorial) processes in eyewitness identification.
Description
Keywords
Eyewitness identification, Academic writing, Research
Citation
Quinlivan, D. S., Wells, G. L., Neuschatz, J. S., Luecht, K. M., Cash, D. K., & Key, K. N. (2017). The Effects of Pre-admonition Suggestions on Eyewitnesses’ Choosing Rates and Retrospective Identification Judgments. Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology: The Official Journal of the Society for Police and Criminal Psychology, 32(3), 236–246. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11896-016-9216-7
DOI
Collections